Grilled Mexican Cheese Sandwich – Oh Sweet Basil

This isn’t your common grilled cheese sandwich! We’re combining 4 completely different cheeses with a flavored butter unfold and an irresistible roasted jalapeño mayo to create a grilled Mexican cheese sandwich.

We stay proper by the mountains and have been loving grabbing the children and heading as much as the mountains to eat and hike or watch a film. A full-of-flavor soup, like taco stew, is a type of hit-the-spot soups that warms you from the within out however don’t cease there! Why not go loopy with a Mexican type grilled cheese filled with cheese, a killer roasted jalapeno mayo and also you guys, the tacky butter unfold on high… I could by no means go away my kitchen once more!

What’s soup when you don’t have one thing to sop up all that deliciousness with?! Taco stew, meet Mexican Grilled Cheese. Let’s fall in love.

Components for Mexican Grilled Cheese

Prepare for all of the cheeses, tacky butter and roasted jalapeno mayo! Here’s a listing of all of the substances you have to to make these indulgent sandwiches:

Sandwich: sourdough bread, Oaxaca cheese, cheddar cheese, Chihuahua cheese, and cotija cheese

Butter: unsalted butter, mayonnaise, cotija cheese, cheddar cheese, cilantro, and chili flakes

Mayo: mayonnaise, garlic powder, onion powder, jalapeno, and pink bell pepper

The right way to Make Mexican Grilled Cheese Sandwiches

Making these sandwiches to gooey perfection is a bit bit like a dance, so let’s get to the kitchen and begin shaking a leg! 

First, combine all of the substances for the flavored butter collectively and set it apart. Then combine all of the substances for the mayo collectively and set it apart. Then we are going to bounce into assembling the sandwiches. This works greatest you probably have all of the cheese sliced and able to go.

1. Warmth a big skillet or griddle over medium warmth and butter one facet of a slice of the bread with the butter. Put the buttered-side of the bread down on the skillet.
2. Unfold a number of the mayo all around the different facet of the bread. 
3. Prime with half of the cheeses.
4. Take one other slice of bread and smear the mayo on one facet. Put the saucy facet of the bread down on high of the cheeses and butter the surface of the bread. 
5. Flip the sandwich as soon as the facet that’s down on the skillet is golden brown. Let it prepare dinner on the second facet till the cheese is all melty.
6. Repeat these steps with the opposite two slices of bread and the remaining cheeses.
7. Serve with soup!

Did you catch all these steps? It’s not too difficult, however you simply wish to be sure you get the butter and the sauce on the suitable sides of the bread and all the things is completed in the suitable order. You’re going to like this recipe!

Watch our Mexican Grilled Cheese Video

What Form of Bread is Finest for Grilled Cheese?

We’re all a few good high quality sourdough bread like The Rustik Oven model. It’s so comfortable and chewy but in addition hearty sufficient to deal with all of the goodness packed into this grilled cheese sandwich. In case you aren’t a sourdough lover, then a superb white bread or french bread additionally work nice.

What’s Oaxaca Cheese?

Oaxaca cheese can be known as quesillo or asadero cheese. It’s a white cheese originating from Oaxaca, Mexico that’s related in taste to Monterey Jack cheese however extra like mozzarella cheese in texture. The flavour is buttery and barely salty and it’s nice for melting. It balances the spicy taste typically present in Mexican meals.

It has develop into an increasing number of common and may often be present in giant grocery retailer chains, however when you can’t discover it, first rate substitutes embody mozzarella, Monterey jack, or Muenster.

What’s Chihuahua Cheese?

Chihuahua cheese is constituted of cow’s milk and has a salty, gentle and barely bitter taste. It’s nice for cooking as a result of it melts nicely and will get additional gooey. It originates within the Chihuahua area of northern Mexico.

I’ve really had essentially the most luck discovering it at Costco, and sometimes I discover it at Walmart and Kroger shops. In case you can’t discover it, medium cheddar cheese or Muenster are good substitutes.

The right way to Roast a Jalapeño

I’m not a fan of spicy, however I’m an enormous fan of the flavour that jalapeños add to a dish so one solution to calm the warmth in a jalapeño is to roast it. Scale back the warmth by heating it…is senseless! But it surely works! You possibly can roast jalapeños within the oven or on the stovetop. 

Oven

1. To roast within the oven, transfer your high rack to the very high place in your oven in order that your baking sheet will probably be 3-4 inches from the highest.
2. Preheat the oven to 450 levels Fahrenheit.
3. Clear after which dry your peppers and brush them with a bit little bit of canola oil. Sprinkle them with a bit salt after which place them on a baking sheet.
4. Place the baking sheet within the preheated oven and switch them each 4-5 minutes till they’re charred on all sides.
5. When they’re charred throughout, take away the peppers from the oven and instantly stick them in a plastic bag and seal the bag closed to steam them. Allow them to sit for at the very least quarter-hour.
6. Take away the peppers from the bag. The skins must be simple to take away. Then you possibly can take away the seeds if you’d like and proceed along with your recipe.

Stovetop

1. To roast on the stovetop, you have to have a gasoline vary.
2. Clear and dry your peppers and brush them with a bit canola oil. Sprinkle them with a bit salt.
3. Flip one burner on to medium warmth and utilizing tongs and an oven mitt, rotate every jalapeño over the flame till it chars and blisters on all sides.
4. Place the charred peppers right into a plastic bag to allow them to steam for at the very least quarter-hour.
5. The skins on the peppers ought to then be simple to take away. Take away the seeds if desired and use in your recipe.

What to Eat with Grilled Mexican Cheese Sandwiches

You may eat this grilled Mexican cheese sandwich all by itself, however why would you do this when you can dip it in a delicious soup?! A number of of our favourite soups for dipping this grilled cheese sandwich with a Mexican makeover are our taco stew (like I discussed initially), our cheesy southwestern chicken tortilla soup, our classic chicken tortilla soup or our enchilada chili. 

If you wish to go together with a lighter facet dish, attempt our grilled Mexican street corn (elote), elote corn salad, or our tasty avocado salad.

Can Grilled Mexican Cheese Sandwiches Be Made Forward of Time?

That is a type of meals that’s greatest eaten recent and proper off the pan. The cheese is melty and gooey. The bread is crunchy on the surface and saucy on the within. It doesn’t save nicely, so eat it sizzling!

4 cheeses, good sourdough bread, a flavored butter and a roasted jalapeno mayo all come collectively to take advantage of outrageously scrumptious grilled Mexican cheese sandwich!

Extra Sandwich Recipes You’ll Love:

Really useful Merchandise

REMEMBER TO SUBSCRIBE TO our FREE Oh Candy Basil NEWSLETTER AND RECEIVE EASY RECIPES DELIVERED INTO YOUR INBOX EVERY DAY!

Once you attempt a recipe, please use the hashtag #ohsweetbasil on INSTAGRAM for an opportunity to be featured in our tales!  FOLLOW OH, SWEET BASIL ON FACEBOOK | INSTAGRAM | PINTEREST | TWITTER FOR ALL OF OUR LATEST CONTENT, RECIPES AND STORIES.